Ada County Courthouse in Boise, where Meridian vehicular manslaughter cases are heard

Meridian Vehicular Homicide Defense Attorneys

Charged with Vehicular Homicide in Meridian, Idaho?

Visit our office in downtown Boise, near the Ada County Courthouse

Idaho Code 18-4006(3) covers a misdemeanor, a felony with up to 10 years, and a DUI felony with mandatory minimums, and the Ada County prosecutor picks the letter. The case is heard in Boise, and we appear there.

5.0 Google Reviews
→ Talk to An Attorney Today Schedule Your Free Consultation
Idaho Defense Firm

Experience That Delivers Results

Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case is unique.

Martindale-Hubbell Client Champion - Reviewed Martindale-Hubbell Notable - Peer Rated for Strong Ethical Standards 2026

"Randy was able to get my case dismissed."

– Derek L.

Rape

Reduced to Misdemeanor

Aggravated Battery

Acquittal

Felony Domestic Violence

Acquittal

Possession of Stolen Firearm

Acquittal

Three Letters That Decide a Meridian Fatal-Crash Case

Idaho has no statute called vehicular homicide. What a Meridian driver is charged with after a fatal crash is vehicular manslaughter under Idaho Code 18-4006(3), and that one subsection holds three different crimes. It applies when the operation of a motor vehicle is a significant cause of a death because of (a) an unlawful act not amounting to a felony, committed with gross negligence; (b) a violation of the DUI statute, Idaho Code 18-8004, or of 18-8006; or (c) an unlawful act not amounting to a felony, without gross negligence. The letter the Ada County prosecutor writes on the complaint decides nearly everything that follows.

The ranges in Idaho Code 18-4007 show why. Category (a) is a felony with up to 10 years and $10,000. Category (b) is a felony with up to 15 years and $15,000 on a first offense; with one prior it carries a 5-year mandatory minimum and up to 25 years and $20,000, and with two or more priors a 10-year mandatory minimum and the same 25-year, $20,000 ceiling. Category (c) is a misdemeanor, up to 1 year and $2,000. The same crash can be charged under more than one theory, and the defense’s first job is to make the state prove the letter it chose.

A fatal crash in Meridian is an Ada County case from the first minute. The investigation is done by local police, the Ada County Sheriff’s Office, or Idaho State Police. The charging decision belongs to the Ada County Prosecuting Attorney, and it may come at the scene or weeks later, after the reconstruction and toxicology are in. Anyone arrested is booked at the Ada County Jail at 7200 Barrister Drive, and the case is heard at the Ada County Courthouse at 200 W Front Street in Boise, in Idaho’s Fourth Judicial District. Mr. Barnum has defended serious felonies in Idaho courts for more than two decades. Mr. Wilkerson carried a felony caseload as an Ada County Public Defender from 2019 to 2025 and has argued before the Idaho Supreme Court and the Idaho Court of Appeals. We appear in that courthouse.

Causation, gross negligence, and the test are each the state’s to prove. Call (208) 336-3600 before you give a statement.

The Reconstruction Is Being Written Now. Your Side of It Is Not.

The file that reaches the Ada County prosecutor is built by the investigators, and the charging decision, from a misdemeanor to a felony with a mandatory minimum, can follow the reconstruction and toxicology. Statements given in the meantime and a missed seven-day ITD deadline both shape that decision. Talk directly with a senior attorney now.

Where a Meridian Vehicular Manslaughter Defense Is Won or Lost

Take a scenario we see often. On a weekday morning in Meridian, two cars collide, and the other driver later dies of the injuries. The surviving driver is treated at the hospital, where an officer requests a blood draw, and goes home. No one is arrested. Later, the reconstruction report and the toxicology results reach the Ada County Prosecuting Attorney, and a complaint is filed with one of three letters on it. This section follows that driver.

“Significant cause” is the first word in the statute, and the first defense. Before the state reaches gross negligence or impairment in that scenario, it has to prove that the driver’s operation of the vehicle was a significant cause of the death. Two-car crashes often have more than one cause: the other driver’s movement, the road, the conditions, a mechanical failure. A reconstruction report is an opinion built on measurements, assumptions, and inputs, and each can be examined. We review it with our own expert where the evidence calls for it.

The gross negligence line. Categories (a) and (c) describe the same conduct, an unlawful act not amounting to a felony, separated by whether it was committed with gross negligence. That phrase is the difference between a felony with up to 10 years and a misdemeanor with up to 1 year. For the driver in that scenario, a missed signal, a speed over the limit, or a moment of inattention is what the state will call gross negligence, and what the defense will describe as what it was. It is argued at the preliminary hearing, in motions, and to a jury.

The DUI category adds a second deadline. If the toxicology in that scenario shows a prohibited level and the charge is filed under category (b), there is a criminal case and an administrative one. A failed breath or blood test means a notice of suspension, and under Idaho Code 18-8002A a written hearing request must reach the Idaho Transportation Department within seven calendar days of service. The hearing is limited to the stop, the grounds for believing the driver was impaired, the test result, the equipment, and whether the driver was told the consequences, and it does not stay the suspension. On the criminal side, whether a prior counts is a legal question we take up immediately. The blood draw and the lab work are evidence in both cases.

Booking, bond, and the hearings at 200 W Front Street. If the complaint in that scenario is served with an arrest, the driver is booked at the Ada County Jail and taken before a magistrate without unnecessary delay under Idaho Code 19-515. Bond and release conditions are set there, and bond is posted at the Sheriff’s Office lobby counter at the jail. A felony under category (a) or (b) then goes to a preliminary hearing, within 14 days of the first appearance if the defendant is in custody, or to a grand jury. If bound over, the case is arraigned in Ada County district court. A category (c) misdemeanor stays with a magistrate from arraignment through trial. The Ada County court calendar posts the hearing dates.

What the file contains, and how a case ends. The state’s file in that scenario can hold scene measurements, the reconstruction report, toxicology, event data recorder information from the vehicle, witness accounts, and every statement the driver made. The case resolves by dismissal, by a negotiated charge under a different category, by a withheld judgment where the law allows one, or by a jury verdict at the Ada County Courthouse. We do not promise which. We promise that causation, the gross negligence line, and the reliability of the test and the reconstruction each get put to the state. Call (208) 336-3600. For the path from the jail to the courtroom in Ada County, see our Meridian criminal defense page. The facts of your case will differ. The steps will not.

Talk to a Defense Attorney Who Appears in Ada County.

Free, confidential consultation with a senior attorney. Downtown Boise office, near the Ada County Courthouse.

Reasons to Choose Idaho Defense Firm

Serious Defense. Real Experience.

1

Fatal-Crash Cases Are Tried at 200 W Front Street

A vehicular manslaughter charge from Meridian is prosecuted by the Ada County Prosecuting Attorney and heard at the Ada County Courthouse in Boise. We appear there, at the preliminary hearing and in district court.

2

The Subsection Is the First Fight, and We Know It

Idaho Code 18-4006(3) has three categories with ranges from a misdemeanor to a 10-year mandatory minimum. Mr. Barnum has defended serious felonies in Idaho courts for more than two decades; Mr. Wilkerson carried a felony caseload in Ada County from 2019 to 2025.

3

State and Federal Court Experience

Admitted to the Courts of Idaho, the U.S. District Court for the District of Idaho, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Over 40 years combined on felony and misdemeanor cases in Idaho courts.

4

Direct Access to the Attorney Defending You

Your case is handled by a senior attorney. No hand-offs, no revolving door of associates. You get direct access to the attorney defending you, and your questions get answered.

Facing vehicular manslaughter charges in Meridian? Get answers now.

Meridian Vehicular Homicide Questions, Answered

I was sober. Can Ada County still charge me with vehicular manslaughter?

Yes. Only one of the three categories in Idaho Code 18-4006(3) involves DUI. Category (a) is a death caused by an unlawful act not amounting to a felony, committed with gross negligence. Category (c) is the same kind of unlawful act without gross negligence. A traffic violation that the state says was a significant cause of a death is enough for the prosecutor to file under one of those, with no alcohol or drugs in the picture.

Which version of vehicular manslaughter is a misdemeanor?

Category (c): an unlawful act not amounting to a felony, without gross negligence. Under Idaho Code 18-4007 it carries up to 1 year and $2,000, and in Ada County it stays in the magistrate division. Categories (a) and (b) are felonies, with a preliminary hearing and district court. The distance between (a) and (c) is the words “gross negligence.”

The crash was months ago and I have not been charged. Is it over?

Not necessarily. In fatal-crash cases the charging decision can wait for the reconstruction report and the toxicology results. The Ada County Prosecuting Attorney decides what to file and when. The weeks before that decision are not dead time: your vehicle, your phone, and any dash camera footage should be preserved exactly as they are, and you should not give a narrative statement to investigators without counsel.

I have a prior DUI. What does that do to a fatal-crash charge?

If the charge is filed under category (b), the DUI category, a prior changes the range completely. First offense: up to 15 years and $15,000. With one prior conviction: a 5-year mandatory minimum, up to 25 years and $20,000. With two or more priors: a 10-year mandatory minimum, up to 25 years and $20,000. Whether a prior is properly counted is a question of law and record, and it gets litigated.

Will I be held at the Ada County Jail until trial?

That is decided at the first appearance, which Idaho Code 19-515 requires without unnecessary delay after an arrest. The magistrate sets bond and release conditions, and may refer you to Ada County Pretrial Services for an interview and supervision. If a bond amount is set, it is paid at the Sheriff’s Office lobby counter at 7200 Barrister Drive by cash, cashier’s check, money order, or bail bond service, with a $25 fee per bond; no personal checks or cards.

Does the seven-day ITD deadline apply if the crash is charged as a DUI death?

Yes, if you failed a breath or blood test. The notice of suspension the officer served starts a seven-calendar-day window under Idaho Code 18-8002A to request a hearing in writing from the Idaho Transportation Department. That hearing is separate from the criminal case at 200 W Front Street, and requesting it does not pause the suspension. A first failed test is a 90-day suspension with the first 30 absolute.

Will my case go to a grand jury in Ada County?

A felony charge under category (a) or (b) reaches district court either by a preliminary hearing before a magistrate, within 14 days of the first appearance if you are in custody, or by a grand jury indictment. If a scheduled preliminary hearing is vacated, it means the hearing is being reset or the prosecutor has chosen the grand jury route. The preliminary hearing is the defense’s first chance to cross-examine the reconstruction officer and the witnesses under oath, so we prepare for it as if it will happen.

How much does a vehicular manslaughter lawyer cost in Meridian?

These cases are built on reconstruction, toxicology, and vehicle data, so the fee reflects the category charged, the volume of evidence, and whether the case is headed to a jury at the Ada County Courthouse. This is not a volume practice. A senior attorney handles the case personally and tells you the fee at the free consultation, before you decide anything. Call (208) 336-3600.

Meet Your Defense Team

A Career Dedicated to Criminal Defense

Randall S. Barnum, Criminal Defense Attorney at Idaho Defense Firm

Randall S. Barnum

Attorney

More than two decades of criminal defense in Idaho’s state and federal courts. A.B., UC Berkeley; J.D., Willamette University College of Law. Admitted to the Courts of Idaho, the U.S. District Court for the District of Idaho, and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Member of the Idaho Criminal Justice Act Panel.

Shawn Wilkerson, Criminal Defense Attorney at Idaho Defense Firm

Shawn Wilkerson

Attorney

15+ years of criminal defense, including six years as an Ada County Public Defender handling felony caseloads. B.S., Idaho State University; J.D., University of Idaho College of Law. Has argued before the Idaho Supreme Court and the Idaho Court of Appeals.

Related Criminal Defense Services

We handle a wide range of criminal defense cases across the Treasure Valley.

Call (208) 336-3600 to start your defense today. Your case is handled directly by a senior attorney, no hand-offs, no associates.

What Our Clients Say

Real People. Real Cases. Real Results.

5.0 on Google

"Great attorney, great person. I would recommend Barnum hands down."

Christian P.

Google Review

"Randy was able to get my case dismissed."

Derek L.

Google Review

"Randal did an amazing job for me. I would recommend him to anyone."

Ava R.

Google Review

Serving Ada and Canyon Counties

Criminal defense in every Treasure Valley courtroom, from our office in downtown Boise.

Your Defense Starts With a Conversation.

Every criminal case is different. Contact Idaho Defense Firm to discuss your situation directly with a senior attorney. With over 40 years of combined criminal defense experience in Idaho's state and federal courts, we can help you understand your options and build a defense strategy tailored to your case.

By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your inquiry. Your information is confidential and protected.

Call Message